Thursday, March 26, 2015
In honor of the 10 year anniversary, what are the 10 best stories since Doctor Who returned?
Everyone will have their own choices for this, of course, but here are mine! Feel free to tell me where you agree and where you disagree in the comments!
10. ASYLUM OF THE DALEKS (Series 7 Episode 1, Story 226, written by Steven Moffat)
I was torn with what episode would go here. Also in the running were (in chronological, not necessarily preferential order) DALEK (from series 1), HUMAN NATURE/FAMILY OF BLOOD (from series 3), MIDNIGHT (from series 4), THE STOLEN EARTH/JOURNEY'S END (from series 4), THE ELEVENTH HOUR (from series 5), and THE IMPOSSIBLE ASTRONAUT/DAY OF THE MOON (from series 6). Any of those would definitely be in the discussing for deserving a spot, but I ultimately went with the season opener from series 7.
9. VINCENT AND THE DOCTOR (Series 5 Episode 10, Story 210, written by Ricard Curtis)
8. TURN LEFT (Series 4 Episode 11, Story 197, written by Russell T. Davies)
The second of the three episodes on this list not written by Steven Moffat, TURN LEFT was written by Russell T. Davies who we have to thank for the return of Doctor Who. This is an episode that looks at the world that might have been had Donna not met the Doctor. It also expertly sets up the end of the series and, sadly, the end of Donna's run as one of the best companions the Doctor has ever had.
7. SILENCE IN THE LIBRARY/FOREST OF THE DEAD (Series 4 Episodes 8-9, Story 195, written by Steven Moffat)
Steven Moffat has done a lot of great things for Doctor Who, but his greatest accomplishment might be introducing two of the greatest characters in the Doctor Who universe. One of those he introduced in this creepy two part story in the middle of series 4, River Song. While some people complain about the resolution to the mystery of River Song, there is no denying that the character and the mystery surrounding her captivated viewers. It was fascinating to see a character from the Doctor's future, one who knew him intimately, but the Doctor, like those of us watching the episode, was meeting her for the first time.
6. THE EMPTY CHILD/THE DOCTOR DANCES (Series 1 Episodes 9-10, Story 164, written by Steven Moffat)
Unquestionably one of the scariest episodes in Doctor Who history (I would add a couple that are further along in this list as well as Midnight, which just missed the list to the scariest episodes in NuWho history), it also has one of the best conclusions of any storyline. More importantly, however, is the fact that this story introduces the second of the characters I mentioned during the last story.
This is the story that introduces viewers to Captain Jack Harkness, who would go on to get his own fantastic spinoff, Torchwood.
Also, somehow, Captain Jack is currently in Starling City pretending to be called Malcolm Merlyn (See: Arrow). That would explain the mystery of how he came back to life, at least.
5. THE GIRL IN THE FIREPLACE (Series 2 Episode 4, Story 171, written by Steven Moffat)
An episode that beautifully captures the effect the Doctor can have on a person's entire life. Coming in and out at various times throughout the entirety of the life of Madame du Pompadour (who in real life, share's my birthday, making this a yearly watch for me on my birthday), the Doctor has a profound influence on someone who herself had a profound influence on an entire country. This is also a perfect episode to introduce someone to how great this show can be (although the one I usually use is still to come on this list).
4. LISTEN (Series 8 Episode 4, Story 245, written by Steven Moffat)
3. BLINK (Series 3 Episode 10, Story 186, written by Steven Moffat)
Besides being the first big role for Carey Mulligan who since starred as Daisy in the recent Great Gatsby remake, this is the episode of NuWho that I most often use to show new viewers how great this show can be. The tensions of the Weeping Angels, one of the scariest monsters in the history of the show, the complexity of the plot, and the perfect explanation of the "timey-wimey" nature of the show of which this episode is just a part make this not only one of the best episodes/stories of NuWho, but one of the best in the entire 50 + year history of the show!
2. THE DOCTOR'S WIFE (Series 6 Episode 4, Story 216, written by Neil Gaiman)
An episode that delved into the longest running companion of the entirety of the show, the TARDIS herself. Sci-Fi genius Neil Gaiman (of American Gods, Neverwhere, Stardust, Coraline, Sandman, and much, much more fame) made this the first Doctor Who episode he had ever written, despite being a life long fan of the series. Of course, there is some history of famous Sci-Fi writers working for the show (see Douglas Adams, he of The Hitchhikers Guide to the Galaxy fame). Gaiman's episode brought back the TARDIS corridors to NuWho, which often made an appearance in Classic Who, and personified the TARDIS herself, leading to some great moments that fans didn't know they needed until they actually happened.
1. THE DAY OF THE DOCTOR (50th Anniversary Special, Story 240, written by Steven Moffat)
50 years to the day after the show first aired, this special premiered as the largest world-wide simulcast of all time to that point. Getting back to the heart of who the Doctor really is, this special fixed one of my main problems with NuWho, had a ton of nice Easter Eggs for fans of pre-2005 Doctor Who, and showed exactly how great a meeting of David Tennant's 10th Doctor and Matt Smith's 11th Doctor would be (spoiler alert: exactly as awesome, perhaps even more awesome, as you imagined). This might be my all-time favorite story in the totality of Doctor Who. It doesn't hurt (no pun intended) to add such a great actor into the time between the Doctor Who TV Movie featuring the 8th Doctor and the resurgence of Doctor Who that occurred exactly ten years ago today. Furthermore, this special tied the new series inextricably to the classic series, proving once and for all that the show, despite the hiatus, is still Doctor Who, just like it was on November 23, 1963, just like it was on March 26, 2005, and just like it is today!
Until Next Time, find the majority of these episodes and more on Netflix and celebrate the return to our televisions of Doctor Who with whatever your favorite episodes of the show might be!